This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my Disclosure Policy .
There’s a lot of misconceptions about the difficulty level of a cooking a succulent prime rib. Since a Prime Rib (also called a Standing Rib Roast) is usually a large cut of meat it tends to scare many people. The truth of the matter is, these cuts of beef are not difficult to prepare and with a few simple tricks, you can be cooking them perfectly every time.
Once you see how easy they are you will wonder why you didn’t try it sooner! 😉
My first absolute must have is a good digital thermometer. I have two: The first is a remote digital thermometer with a cord that goes directly into the meat and into the oven. For me, this is the best thermometer for this application. Ours has a Bluetooth type capability where it can talk to a remote receiver up to 300 feet away. We use this also for smoking meats and BBQ outdoors with the receiver in the house. For the roasts, it keeps me from taking the roast in and out of the oven to check the temperature of the meat. It’s an awesome kitchen gadget.
Of course, you can use a traditional meat thermometer but this type is not as accurate as the newer digital thermometers. The new digital thermometers aren’t that costly and are a great addition to any kitchen. My go-to is the digital kitchen thermometer. Since the cook on the meat matters, I’ve gone digital and use mine quite often after the older standard model which now occupies space at the back of my cluttered drawer.
A perfectly cooked Prime Rib is a perfect medium rare. Cooked to medium or beyond, this cut loses flavor and tenderness. If you are not a fan of rare to medium rare steaks and beef, this cut is not worth the expense for you. I would try instead a roast crown of pork or a bottom round pot roast.
The second thing I recommend is talking to the butcher at your local market. I find often only a few Prime Rib roasts are on display at a time – and generally only during the holidays. If you need a larger (or smaller) cut, they can be either special order one or cut one to order. My butcher precuts the ribs off the meat for me, either fully or partially, and then ties the ribs and the roast back together with butchers string. This is completely safe for the oven and won’t burn. Leave it in place. You just snip the strings when the roast is done and the ribs remove easily off the roast. We set these aside for later. There’s always one person willing to enjoy these later. They are also good for making beef bone broth.
Letting the roast rest is key to Perfect Prime Rib. This allows the juices to redistribute and believe it or not, the roast will continue to cook for the next 20 minutes while it’s out of the oven and resting. Many a Perfect Prime Rib is lost during those last 20 minutes. The resting time is crucial. So be patient; let it rest.
To determine how large a roast you need for your guests, calculate 3/4 to 1-pound per person for a bone-in roast. This will also depend on the number of sides being served, the number of courses being served, and if you are serving two main dishes (like Turkey and Prime Rib). For 8 people, I bought an 8-pound bone-in roast for our main course. We will serve this with loaded baked potatoes, au jus, creamy horseradish sauce, creamed spinach, and oven roasted broccoli and cauliflower.
While Prime rib is tender, succulent and undeniably delicious, the price point is sometimes more than we can spend on a Holiday or Sunday Supper. One good substitute for Prime Rib which is the often overlooked is the Eye of Round Roast. Eye of round is best when cooked to medium-rare and sliced thin against the grain. This perfectly tender eye of round roast takes just over 30-minutes in the oven for a perfect medium-rare. Perfect for Sunday supper or even a holiday dinner.
PRO KITCHEN TIP: Cooking time will vary depending on the size of the roast. Calculate the actual weight by 15 (minutes per pound) and then divide that number by 60 to get your approximate time. For example: A 7.89 pound roast x 15 mins per pound = 118.35 minutes / 60 minutes per hour = 1.97 hours.
According to our formula, an 8-pound roast will take about 2 hours to cook. Again. Do NOT rely solely on smell or this cooking formula to roast your Prime rib to perfection. Instead, invest in a digital kitchen thermometer and roast based on temperature. This is the only way to ensure the Perfect Prime Rib each and every time.
Perfect Prime Rib
- 1 Prime Rib (Standing Rib) Roast; 5 pounds
- 1/4 cup black pepper
- 1/4 cup kosher salt , large crystals for a better crust
- 2 tablespoons herbes de Provence (optional)
- 2 large minced garlic cloves
Optional Serving Suggestions:
- Au jus beef stock sauce
- creamy horseradish sauce
- Cooking times will vary depending on the size of the roast you select. As a rule of thumb, figure on 15 minutes per pound to calculate the average cooking time for your roast. However, when it comes time to cook the roast, don't just follow your nose or rely on time alone to judge when the meat is cooked properly. Use a digital thermometer for optimal results.
- To cook: Preheat your oven to 450 degrees F for at least 30 minutes while the prime rib comes to room temperature.
- Place the roast in a roasting pan bone-side down. The bones create its own roasting rack for the meat. If you prefer, you may also place the roast up on a roasting rack.
- Cook the roast for 15 minutes at 450 degrees F, then reduce the oven temperature to 325 degrees F. Remember to estimate about 15 minutes of cooking time per pound of prime rib.
- Continue to cook the roast until your meat thermometer reads 110 degrees F.
- Once the thermometer hits 110 degrees F, remove the roast from the oven and allow it rest for 20 minutes.You can tent the roast if you like, but it is not necessary. During the resting time, the roast will continue to cook using the heat inside the roast, raising the internal temperature to 130 degrees for a perfect medium-rare prime rib.
- Once the meat has rested fully and come to 130 degrees F, snip the butcher's string and remove the bones from the roast. Slice and serve.
- Cooking time will vary depending on the size of the roast. Calculate the actual weight by 15 (minutes per pound) and then divide that number by 60 to get your approximate time.
- For example: A 7.89 pound roast x 15 mins per pound = 118.35 minutes / 60 minutes per hour = 1.97 hours. According to our formula, an 8-pound roast will take about 2 hours to cook.
- Do NOT rely solely on smell or this cooking formula to roast your Prime rib to perfection. Instead, invest in an internal meat thermometer and roast based on temperature. This is the only way to ensure the Perfect Prime Rib each and every time.