How to Make Homemade Butter (2 Easy Methods)

There’s something downright magical about making homemade butter from heavy cream. One minute the cream is sloshing around like a milkshake, and the next—bam!—you’ve made real butter at home.

No factory. No mystery ingredients. Just two simple ingredients, a little movement, and that “I can’t believe I just made butter?” moment.

If you’ve ever wondered how to make homemade butter, this easy homemade butter recipe will make you feel like a cozy kitchen wizard—no special equipment required.

---

Why Make Homemade Butter?

Let’s be real—you can buy butter anywhere. But making it yourself?

That’s a whole different vibe.

Homemade butter is:

• Fresh and rich
• Shockingly easy
• A great beginner kitchen win
• Fun for kids (or stressed adults 😅)
• A two-for-one recipe (hello, buttermilk!)

It’s old-fashioned, satisfying, and makes even basic toast feel fancy.

---

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

It uses just ONE ingredient.
If you can pour cream into a jar, you can make butter. No fancy tools, no special skills, no stress.

It feels like kitchen magic.
Watching cream turn into butter never gets old. It’s one of those “wait… I made this?” moments that builds instant confidence.

It’s fun for kids and adults.
Shake it, whip it, laugh a little—this recipe turns cooking into an experience, not a chore.

You get two things at once.
Fresh butter and real buttermilk. That’s a bonus recipe without extra work (or dishes).

It tastes fresher than store-bought.
Homemade butter has a clean, rich flavor that makes toast, biscuits, and bread taste extra special.

It’s endlessly customizable.
Salt it, sweeten it, add herbs, or swirl in honey—this butter becomes whatever you want it to be.

It’s a back-to-basics win.
Simple ingredients. Old-school technique. Cozy results. This recipe reminds you why cooking at home is so satisfying.

---

---

Ingredients for Homemade Butter

What You Need

• Heavy whipping cream (very cold works best)
• Salt (optional, to taste)

That’s it. Butter is living its best minimalist life.

---

How Butter Works (Quick + Friendly Science)

Cream is full of tiny fat droplets floating in liquid.
When you shake or whip it, those fat droplets bump into each other and stick together.

Eventually:

• The fat clumps into butter
• The liquid left behind becomes buttermilk

Science never tasted so good.

---

---

How to Make Homemade Butter (2 Easy Methods)

Method 1: Mason Jar Butter (The Fun One)

This is the classic, no-equipment method. This method is perfect for beginners and kids.

You’ll Need

• A mason jar with a tight lid
• Heavy cream (fill the jar halfway)

Steps

1. Pour cream into the jar. Don’t overfill—give it room to move.
2. Screw the lid on tight.
3. Shake the jar like you mean it.
4. First, it sloshes. Then it thickens. Then suddenly… butter forms!
5. Keep shaking until the butter clumps clearly separate from the liquid.

⏱️ Time: about 5–10 minutes
💪 Arm Day workout: included

Tip: Kids LOVE this job. Also great for burning off frustration.

---

Method 2: Mixer Butter (Fast & Easy) – Be Careful not to Overchurn

If shaking sounds like a chore, grab your mixer. This is the fastest way to make homemade butter, but it’s easy to overchurn.

Steps

1. Pour cream into a mixing bowl [paid link].
2. Beat on medium speed.
3. Watch it go from:
   • Cream → whipped cream → over-whipped → butter + liquid
4. Stop once large butter clumps form.

Pro tip: Cover the bowl loosely. Buttermilk likes to splatter.

---

Rinse the Butter (Don’t Skip This!)

This step helps your butter last longer.

1. Scoop the butter into a bowl.
2. Pour cold water over it.
3. Gently press and squeeze the butter.
4. Drain and repeat until the water runs clear.

Think of it as a spa day for your butter.

---

Salt It (Or Get Fancy)

Now comes the fun part.

Classic Salted Butter

• Sprinkle in salt to taste
• Mix gently

---

Flavor Ideas

• Honey butter
• Garlic herb butter
• Cinnamon sugar butter
• Lemon zest + sea salt
• Roasted garlic butter

Shape it however you like:

• Roll it in parchment
• Press into a small dish
• Scoop and swirl for that bakery look

---

Common Homemade Butter Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)

How to fix overchurned butter

First: What “Overchurned” Butter Means

Overchurned butter usually looks:

• Very grainy or crumbly
• Extra dry
• Or like tiny butter pebbles instead of one smooth mass

This happens when the fat squeezes out too much liquid. Totally fixable.

---

The Cold Water Rescue

This works 90% of the time.

1. Put the butter in a bowl.
2. Pour very cold water over it.
3. Gently press and knead it together with a spoon or clean hands.
4. Drain and repeat once or twice.

👉 The cold water helps the fat relax and bind back together.

---

Still Crumbly? Try This

Add a Teaspoon of Cream or Buttermilk

• Add ½–1 teaspoon at a time
• Gently work it in
• Stop as soon as it smooths out

You’re basically giving the butter a sip of hydration

If It’s REALLY Far Gone

No shame—this happens. But all is not lost …

Turn It Into:

• Whipped butter (beat it lightly)
• Compound butter (add herbs, honey, garlic)
• Cooking butter for sautéing or baking

Once melted, texture doesn’t matter—and the flavor is still great.

What Not to Do

• Don’t keep beating it
• Don’t add warm liquid
• Don’t microwave it to “fix” it (that’s just melted butter now)

How to Prevent It Next Time

• Stop mixing as soon as butter clumps together
• Switch to low speed once separation starts
• Rinse gently—don’t aggressively squeeze
• Chill the butter briefly before shaping

---

What About the Remaining Liquid? Hello, Buttermilk!

That leftover liquid is real buttermilk, not the store-bought substitute.

Use it for:

• Waffles
• Scones
• Cornbread
• Fried chicken

Store it in the fridge and use it within a few days.

One recipe. Two jars. That’s a win.

---

---

What to Serve with Homemade Butter

This butter shines on:

• Garlic bread
• No-Knead Oatmeal Bread
• Bread Machine English Muffins
• Biscuits
• Pancakes
• Corn on the cob
• Baked potatoes
• easy pasta recipe

---

Storage Tips

• Unsalted butter: 5–7 days in the fridge
• Salted butter: up to 2 weeks
• Frozen: up to 6 months

Wrap tightly so it doesn’t absorb fridge smells. Butter that tastes like leftovers is… not dreamy.

---

People Also Ask: Homemade Butter FAQs

Can I use ultra-pasteurized cream to make homemade butter?
Yes. Ultra-pasteurized heavy cream works just fine for making homemade butter.

Why is my homemade butter soft?
Homemade butter is usually soft when it’s warm. Chilling it will help it firm up.

Why does homemade butter taste different than store-bought butter?
Homemade butter is fresher and less processed, which gives it a richer flavor.

Can I make butter at home without a mixer or a mason jar?
Yes. A food processor [paid link] or whisk [paid link] will work, but a mason jar or stand mixer [paid link] is the easiest method.

Can overchurned butter be fixed?
Yes. If butter looks grainy or crumbly, it has released too much liquid. See the How to Fix Overchurned Butter section above.

---

---

---